2014 Brawl For All, Who wins?

[cero2k]

say WWE where to run a Brawl For All today with the current roster (assuming everyone is healthy) , who do you think would win the tournament?

for those who don't remember, Brawl for All was a shoot fight tournament that WWF ran back in the day. Huge failure IMO since as you can imagine, a lot of the guys are not trained fighters and would end up getting knocked out easily.

[Big Red Machine]

Lesnar.

[cero2k]

Lesnar.

ok true, i think having lesnar in the competition makes this answer easy. say lesnar is not in, who would you go for?

[Big Red Machine]

Probably Swagger.
Who else can shoot? Dolph? Bryan?

[cero2k]

Probably Swagger.
Who else can shoot? Dolph? Bryan?

now that Del Rio is gone, my vote is for Barrett, being a bare knuckle fighter should account for something.

[Big Red Machine]

Probably Swagger.
Who else can shoot? Dolph? Bryan?

now that Del Rio is gone, my vote is for Barrett, being a bare knuckle fighter should account for something.

That's true. He's another guy who could win it. I guess it would really depend on the rules.

[Bob-O]

Butterbean!!! Can I pick Butterbean!?

Probably Swagger.
Who else can shoot? Dolph? Bryan?

now that Del Rio is gone, my vote is for Barrett, being a bare knuckle fighter should account for something.

That's true. He's another guy who could win it. I guess it would really depend on the rules.

Dolph I don't think is trained in anything but salesmanship.

Bryan has plenty of "training" but none of it has ever been applied to anyone who was trying to do it back.

Was Barrett actually a bare knuckle fighter!? I thought that was just a gimmick he had in FCW...

Swagger was a good amateur wrestler, and Cody Rhodes claims to have been, but Brawl For All was never about tap outs or mat skills, sure you got points for takedowns but the winners of these Tough Man type things is always the guy that can take your punches and knock you out with one of his. For that reason, I like Cesaro. The dude's just so effing strong, I don't care who he's in there with he'd only have to hit 'em once.

In a Dark Horse sort of way, I'd also like Erik Rowan in this sort of thing. The huge sloppy guy, with not a whole lot to lose but pride, running in there throwing haymakers right off the bat. Guys like Erik are why I'd say guys like Bryan and Rhodes wouldn't stand a chance...

I think Big E'd be fun to watch, as would Bray Wyatt and Rusev... but in the end, I think Cesaro takes it.

[Big Red Machine]

Butterbean!!! Can I pick Butterbean!?

That's true. He's another guy who could win it. I guess it would really depend on the rules.

Dolph I don't think is trained in anything but salesmanship.

Dolph was a top amateur wrestler in college, and had his school's record for pins.

Bryan has plenty of "training" but none of it has ever been applied to anyone who was trying to do it back.

I know he has at least sparred. I don't think he's ever been in a sanctioned tournament or anything.

Was Barrett actually a bare knuckle fighter!? I thought that was just a gimmick he had in FCW...

Yes. This was legit.

Swagger was a good amateur wrestler, and Cody Rhodes claims to have been, but Brawl For All was never about tap outs or mat skills, sure you got points for takedowns but the winners of these Tough Man type things is always the guy that can take your punches and knock you out with one of his. For that reason, I like Cesaro. The dude's just so effing strong, I don't care who he's in there with he'd only have to hit 'em once.

In a Dark Horse sort of way, I'd also like Erik Rowan in this sort of thing. The huge sloppy guy, with not a whole lot to lose but pride, running in there throwing haymakers right off the bat. Guys like Erik are why I'd say guys like Bryan and Rhodes wouldn't stand a chance...

I think Big E'd be fun to watch, as would Bray Wyatt and Rusev... but in the end, I think Cesaro takes it.

That's what I said it depends on the rules. If it is basically a shoot fight, I'd go with Swagger or MAYBE Dragon or Dolph. If it is a boxing thing the way the old brawl for all was, I'd give it to Wade or Big Show (who I believe is also has boxing training).

[KILLdozer]

Here's one even better: Who would win in a Brawl For All , out of the members of this site?

Lol its bound to provide endless amounts of entertainment.

[NWK2000]

Am I the only one who thinks Hideo Itami would be the one to win The Brawl for All?
Those kicks