Every 4+ star match in TNA history (up to 2013)

[cero2k]

Source + Meltzer's ratings

NWA/TNA Weekly PPV #2 - Low Ki vs Jerry Lynn vs AJ Styles vs Psicosis
NWA/TNA Weekly PPV #8 - Low Ki vs Jerry Lynn vs AJ Styles
NWA/TNA Weekly PPV #11 - Low Ki vs Jerry Lynn vs AJ Styles (Ladder)
NWA/TNA Weekly PPV #19 - Jerry Lynn vs AJ Styles
NWA/TNA Weekly PPV #39 - Amazing Red & Jerry Lynn vs Christopher Daniels & Elix Skipper vs Jonny Storm & Chris Sabin vs Jason Cross & Shark Boy
NWA/TNA Weekly PPV #40 - Amazing Red & Jerry Lynn vs Christopher Daniels & Elix Skipper
NWA/TNA Weekly PPV #50 - Christopher Daniels & Elix Skipper vs America's Most Wanted (Cage)
NWA/TNA Weekly PPV #59 - AJ Styles vs Raven
NWA/TNA Weekly PPV #60 - Juventud Guerrera vs Teddy Hart; Juventud Guerrera vs Chris Sabin
NWA/TNA Weekly PPV #103 - Chase Stevens & Andy Douglas vs America's Most Wanted (Cage)
Victory Road 2004 - X-Division Rumble
Turning Point 2004 - Petey Williams vs Chris Sabin; Christopher Daniels & Elix Skipper vs America's Most Wanted (Cage)
Final Resolution 2005 - Bobby Roode & Eric Young vs America's Most Wanted; AJ Styles vs Petey Williams vs Chris Sabin (Ultimate X)
Against All Odds 2005 - AJ Styles vs Christopher Daniels (Iron Man)
Lockdown 2005 - AJ Styles vs Abyss (Cage)
No Surrender 2005 - Samoa Joe vs Chris Sabin; AJ Styles vs Sean Waltman
Sacrifice 2005 - AJ Styles vs Samoa Joe
Unbreakable 2005 - AJ Styles vs Samoa Joe vs Christopher Daniels
Bound for Glory 2005 - Abyss vs Rhyno vs Jeff Hardy vs Sabu (Monster's Ball); AJ Styles vs Christopher Daniels
Impact 11/3/05 - Samoa Joe, Christopher Daniels & Alex Shelley vs AJ Styles, Sonjay Dutt & Austin Aries
Genesis 2005 - Rhino & The Dudley Boys vs Jeff Jarrett & America's Most Wanted
Turning Point 2005 - AJ Styles vs Samoa Joe
Final Resolution 2006 - Samoa Joe vs Christopher Daniels
Against All Odds 2006 - AJ Styles vs Samoa Joe vs Christopher Daniels
Destination X 2006 - Chris Sabin vs Sonjay Dutt vs Puma vs Petey Williams
Impact 4/13/06 - Samoa Joe vs Christopher Daniels
Hard Justice 2006 - Samoa Joe vs Monty Brown vs Rhino (Falls Count Anywhere)
No Surrender 2005 - AJ Styles & Christopher Daniels vs L.A.X. (Ultimate X)
Bound for Glory 2006 - Chris Sabin vs Senshi; AJ Styles & Christopher Daniels vs L.A.X. (Cage)
Genesis 2006 - Samoa Joe vs Kurt Angle
Turning Point 2006 - Samoa Joe vs Kurt Angle
Destination X 2007 - Samoa Joe vs Christian Cage
Lockdown 2007 - Christian Cage, Tomko, Abyss, Scott Steiner & AJ Styles vs Kurt Angle, Sting, Samoa Joe, Rhino & Jeff Jarrett (Lethal Lockdown)
Sacrifice 2007 - Jay Lethal vs Chris Sabin vs Sonjay Dutt; James Storm vs Chris Harris (Texas Deathmatch)
Slammiversary 2007 - AJ Styles vs Samoa Joe vs Chris Harris vs Christian Cage vs Kurt Angle (King of the Mountain)
Bound for Glory 2007 - Christian Cage vs Samoa Joe
Genesis 2007 - Christian Cage vs Kazarian (Ladder)
Lockdown 2008 - Kurt Angle vs Samoa Joe (Cage)
Victoria Road 2008 - Alex Shelley, Chris Sabin & Curry Man vs Ultimo Guerrero, Rey Bucaner & Averno vs Tyson Dux, Doug Williams & Alex Koslov vs Masato Yoshino, Puma & Milano Collection AT (Elimination)
Hard Justice 2008 - AJ Styles vs Kurt Angle (Last Man Standing)
Turning Point 2008 - Kurt Angle vs Abyss (Falls Count Anywhere)
Genesis 2009 - Chris Sabin vs Alex Shelley; Kurt Angle vs Jeff Jarrett
Destination X 2009 - Jay Lethal vs Suicide vs Consequences Creed vs Chris Sabin vs Alex Shelley (Ultimate X)
Hard Justice 2009 - Christopher Daniels vs Suicide vs Consequences Creed vs Alex Shelley vs Chris Sabin vs Jay Lethal vs Amazing Red vs D'angelo Dinero (Cage)
Impact 10/15/09 - Kurt Angle vs AJ Styles
Bound for Glory 2009 - Kurt Angle vs Matt Morgan
Turning Point 2009 - Kurt Angle vs Desmond Wolfe; AJ Styles vs Samoa Joe vs Christopher Daniels
Final Resolution 2009 - Kurt Angle vs Desmond Wolfe (3 Stages of Hell); AJ Styles vs Christopher Daniels
Impact 1/4/10 - AJ Styles vs Kurt Angle
Genesis 2010 - AJ Styles vs Kurt Angle
Lockdown 2010 - Kurt Angle vs Mr. Anderson (Cage)
Slammiversary 2010 - Kurt Angle vs Kazarian
Victory Road 2010 - Beer Money vs The Motor City Machine Guns
Impact 7/15/10 - Beer Money vs The Motor City Machine Guns (Ladder)
Impact 8/12/10 - Beer Money vs The Motor City Machine Guns (2/3 Falls)
No Surrender 2010 - Jeff Hardy vs Kurt Angle
Bound for Glory 2010 - The Motor City Machine Guns vs Generation Me; Jeff Hardy vs Kurt Angle vs Mr. Anderson
Final Resolution 2010 - AJ Styles vs Doug Williams
Against All Odds 2011 - Kurt Angle vs Jeff Jarrett
Lockdown 2011 - Kurt Angle vs Jeff Jarrett (2/3 Falls); Christopher Daniels, Robert Roode, James Storm & Kazarian vs Ric Flair, Matt Hardy, Abyss & Bully Ray (Lethal Lockdown)
Slammiversary 2011 - Bully Ray vs AJ Styles (Last Man Standing)
Destination X 2011 - Austin Aries vs Low Ki vs Zema Ion vs Jack Evans
Sacrifice 2012 - Kurt Angle vs AJ Styles
Impact 5/24/12 - Bobby Roode vs AJ Styles
Slammiversary 2012 - Kurt Angle & AJ Styles vs Bad Influence
Destination X 2012 - AJ Styles vs Christopher Daniels (Last Man Standing); Bobby Roode vs Austin Aries
Hardcore Justice 2012 - Bobby Roode vs Austin Aries
Bound For Glory 2012 - Kurt Angle & AJ Styles vs Bad Influence vs Chavo Guerrero & Homicide; Austin Aries vs Jeff Hardy
Turning Point 2012 - Jeff Hardy vs Austin Aries (Ladder)
Genesis 2013 - Jeff Hardy vs Austin Aries vs Bobby Roode
Slammiversary 2013 - Kurt Angle vs AJ Styles
Impact 8/1/13 - Austin Aries vs AJ Styles
Impact 10/31/13 - Bobby Roode vs Kurt Angle

[badnewzxl]

Great list!