I have only really been able to find Meltzer's ratings for PPVs, current ROH PPVs, and, from about 2007 and back, just a few house shows, and nothing from Meltzer for almost any other indy. Does Dave just not watch the other stuff? Or can I just not find it (like, i would love to know what rating Dave gave Danielson vs. Ki from the 2nd ROH show, or the CHIKARA Cibernetico from 2010, Finlay vs. Calihan, or Quack vs. Kingston)?

Is the reason that Dave hasn't given certain matches ***** because he didn't think they were that good... or jest because he hasn't seen them yet?

i honestly have no idea. I'll try to look some up