I have heard a lot of people saying that they think that being live will help or has helped TNA. I just don't see it at all. I don't enjoy Raw any more than I do Impact, Smackdown, FCW, or ROH due to the fact t hat it is live. Knowing that I am watching something that is taped has no bearing on my enjoyment of the show at all.

What about you guys? Does being live make something more enjoyable to you?

Doesn't make much difference for me whether it's live on TV or not. I wouldn't especially like to see them redo the finish of a match three times on live TV like they did when we saw Smackdown live.

Seriously though, there are benefits to being taped that I don't think you get with live TV. But in this era of social networking I think being live gives you more opportunities for fan input.

I don't think it should personally matter for the promotion or the wrestlers whether is live or not, thus it shouldn't really matter in terms of quality of the show...

furthermore, i think it just makes the show a bit more real when you can't re-take a fuck up, and most importantly, it forces everyone to 1-up their work. You can't just afford to let someone come out and screw up. This eventually filters out the bad talent.

however, personally, I prefer a live show just because i don't get spoiled. I hadn't watched TNA impact for more than a year simply because i already knew what was happening, and by the time the show came out, i had already heard about all the things that were gonna me make facepalm. Same with Smackdown. Now however, with a live Impact, i'm more willing to watch it (if there is no other thing worth doing) just to see what happens. That's why i watch RAW, cuz things happen there and no one can anticipate them.

You may say, well, don't read spoilers. It's not that easy, i have to spend at least 1 hr reading wrestling news here and there for the site. sadly, i can never go spoiler free

the big reason going live helps is that ppl can't completely spoil your show. That's a major benefit of going live.

Personally, tho, it doesn't matter much to me. I read spoilers and still watch.....

It's always mattered to me. Spoilers do play a part, I can't just NOT read them. They're there. It's like, a secret..... that I CAN BE IN ON. I don't have the will power! If it's there, I gotta know! I gotta be in on that crap, man!

I can't DVR sporting events either. If I've gotta work through The Steeler's game, or whatever, I'll have it on the radio. If I can't do that, I'm on my phone checking the score every five minutes. Watching something I know already happened just isn't as good.

Watching something live makes it an event. Watching a produced recording makes it a television program. Both are good, but I'd rather be watching an event. The live factor makes me feel involved.

Bob-O wrote:
Watching something live makes it an event. Watching a produced recording makes it a television program. Both are good, but I'd rather be watching an event. The live factor makes me feel involved.

Okay, this I can sort of understand, although Raw never felt that much different to me, but PPVs do.

Big Red Machine wrote:

Bob-O wrote:
Watching something live makes it an event. Watching a produced recording makes it a television program. Both are good, but I'd rather be watching an event. The live factor makes me feel involved.

Okay, this I can sort of understand, although Raw never felt that much different to me, but PPVs do.

one thing to consider where live does indeed matter. things like Nexus, Punk's promo, Lesnar's return. those things wouldn't work on a pre-taped show. or wouldn't create the impact that they created

cero2k wrote:

Big Red Machine wrote:

Bob-O wrote:
Watching something live makes it an event. Watching a produced recording makes it a television program. Both are good, but I'd rather be watching an event. The live factor makes me feel involved.

Okay, this I can sort of understand, although Raw never felt that much different to me, but PPVs do.

one thing to consider where live does indeed matter. things like Nexus, Punk's promo, Lesnar's return. those things wouldn't work on a pre-taped show. or wouldn't create the impact that they created

Sure they would, if people were spoiler free. You would still have 99% of the people see it at the same time.

Obviously if they had done it taped it would have gotten spoiled, but that doesn't effect the feel of it (at least not to me).

It doesn't really bother me whether it's live or not. If the programme is entertaining then I'll enjoy it either way

I agree with Badnewz if it is live then no-one can spoil it for u by telling u the results. Tbh us brits sometimes don't get to see "live shows" that often anyway

For example TNA is filmed on Thursday's(??) in the US. Yet we see it on Sundays then repeated on Tuesdays

Same with their PPV's. I'm sure we usually see them on Wednesday nights

the only way i think it matters is when they do the taping with several weeks in advanced. Smackdown is ok because it's taped three days before. but when TNA was doing tapings like 3 weeks prior, or how ROH is doing it right now, it is a pain in the ass. by the time you see the show, either you're spoiled, or they're using references that may not be relevant anymore. When Roderick Strong won the tv title, it was followed by a roh tv taping where lethal still had it!! it was annoying as hell!!