My list:

Honorable mentions (in no particular order):
Sheamus vs. John Morrison- WWE TLC
Tyler Black vs. Christopher Daniels- ROH Fade to Black
Kevin Steen & Steve Corino vs. El Generico & Colt Cabana- ROH Glory By Honor IX
Tyler Black vs. Kevin Steen- ROH Salvation
Kings of Wrestling vs. Briscoe Brothers- ROH Death Before Dishonor VIII
Kings of Wrestling vs. MCMG- ROH Supercard of Honor V
Roderick Strong vs. Davey Richards- ROH on HDnet (January 4th)
Tyler Black vs. Chris Hero- ROH Bitter Friends, Stiffer Enemies II
Team WWE vs. Team Nexus- WWE Summer Slam
Tyler Black vs. Davey Richards - ROH on HDnet

10. Manami Toyota & Mike Quackenbush vs. Sara Del Rey & Claudio Castagnoli- CHIKARA Though Savage Progress Cuts the Jungle Line
9. Tyler Black vs. Austin Aries- ROH 8th Anniversary Show
8. AJ Styles vs. Kurt Angle- TNA Impact (January 4th)
7. Kane vs. Edge. vs. Del Rio vs. Mysterio- WWE TLC
6. Naomichi Marufuji vs. Katsuhiko Nakajima- NOAH (some time in February, don't remember the date)
5. Davey Richards vs. Roderick Strong- ROH Final Battle 2010
4. MCMG vs. Beer Money- TNA The Whole F'N Show
3. Kevin Steen vs. El Generico- ROH Final Battle 2010
2. Shawn Michaels vs. Undertaker- WWE Wrestlemania XXVI
1. Tyler Black vs. Davey Richards- ROH Death Before Dishonor VIII

This may be a bit hard, can't remember all of them.

10. Sabu vs L.A. Park - X-LAW Show around March
09. MCMG vs Gen Me - Full Metal Mayhem
08. AJ Styles vs Kurt Angle - TNA Impact
07. Evans vs Nosawa vs Daniels vs Extreme Tiger - Triplemania 18
06. KENTA vs Marafuji - Dec 6 show @ Japan (Some memorial show)
05. Taker vs HBK - WM 2something
04. Beer Money Inc vs MCMG - The Whole F'n Show
03. WGTT vs KOW - GBH 9
02. Davey Richards vs Tyler Black - DBD VIII
01. Steen vs Generico - Final Battle 2010

Honorable mention
- Angle vs Amazing Red @ Impact
- Dragon vs Jericho @ NXT
- Team Smackdown vs Team Raw @ Braggin Rights
- LayCool vs Natalya/Phoenix @ TLC