Page 9 of 20

Re: Your 5 star matches

Posted: Aug 20th, '15, 09:46
by cero2k
Meltzer just gave Tanahashi v Nakamura from the G1 finals a 5 star.
Nakamura v Okada and Tanahashi v Styles from the previous nights got 4.75

Re: Your 5 star matches

Posted: Aug 20th, '15, 10:07
by Big Red Machine
cero2k wrote:Meltzer just gave Tanahashi v Nakamura from the G1 finals a 5 star.
Apparently it's one of those "history" matches that plays into their past matches. I can totally respect the ***** rating for that, but I'm not going to go back and watch years' worth of Tanahashi vs. Nakamura matches to see if it really deserves the rating.

Re: Your 5 star matches

Posted: Sep 12th, '15, 20:05
by Big Red Machine
Upon re-watching the match, I have given Nigel McGuinness vs. Tyler Black from ROH Take No Prisoners the full 10/10. This gives Nigel McGuinness three 10/10s in just five weeks- the only person so far to have accomplished that feat (and against three different opponents to boot).

Re: Your 5 star matches

Posted: Nov 12th, '15, 21:51
by Big Red Machine
Just added Thatcher vs. Gargano from Evolve 51. Everyone go see it now!

Re: Your 5 star matches

Posted: Jan 4th, '16, 13:56
by Big Red Machine
Okada and Tanahashi did it again!

Re: Your 5 star matches

Posted: Jan 30th, '16, 17:32
by Big Red Machine
Will Ospreay vs. Marty Scurll from Rev Pro's High Stakes 2016 is my new Match of the Year. As in better than Okada vs. Tanahashi. Better than ANY match Okada and Tanahashi have ever had. Like... a possible Match of the Decade.

Re: Your 5 star matches

Posted: Jan 31st, '16, 11:15
by cero2k
Big Red Machine wrote:Will Ospreay vs. Marty Scurll from Rev Pro's High Stakes 2016 is my new Match of the Year. As in better than Okada vs. Tanahashi. Better than ANY match Okada and Tanahashi have ever had. Like... a possible Match of the Decade.
where did you find it? i've been looking for it all week

Re: Your 5 star matches

Posted: Feb 1st, '16, 22:42
by cero2k
Big Red Machine wrote:Will Ospreay vs. Marty Scurll from Rev Pro's High Stakes 2016 is my new Match of the Year. As in better than Okada vs. Tanahashi. Better than ANY match Okada and Tanahashi have ever had. Like... a possible Match of the Decade.
fucking A Red, you were right, that match was brilliant! now i'm curious to watch the one at Progress since that one had a bit more story and stakes

Re: Your 5 star matches

Posted: Mar 28th, '16, 07:10
by Big Red Machine
Meltzer just put over the O'Reilly vs. KUSHIDA match as it airs on AXS (JR and Josh Barnett calling it) as "getting better every time" he watches it. The first time he saw it Dave gave it ****3/4, and few of us had it in that same area. Might be worth a re-watch.

Re: Your 5 star matches

Posted: Mar 28th, '16, 07:36
by cero2k
Big Red Machine wrote:Meltzer just put over the O'Reilly vs. KUSHIDA match as it airs on AXS (JR and Josh Barnett calling it) as "getting better every time" he watches it. The first time he saw it Dave gave it ****3/4, and few of us had it in that same area. Might be worth a re-watch.
i had it in my top 5 last year, maybe the JR/Barnett can really make a difference

Re: Your 5 star matches

Posted: Apr 2nd, '16, 23:28
by Big Red Machine
Zayn vs. Nakamura gets the full 10 from me

Re: Your 5 star matches

Posted: Aug 14th, '16, 00:30
by Big Red Machine
OMFG OMEGA VS. NAITO! This might have been better than Ospreay vs. Scurll.

Re: Your 5 star matches

Posted: Aug 16th, '16, 13:25
by NWK2000
Zayn vs Nakamura at Takeover Dallas
Gargano vs Ciampa at the Crusierweight Classic
Itami and Balor vs The Ascension at Takeover R Evolution
Brock vs Cena at SS 2014

Re: Your 5 star matches

Posted: Sep 26th, '16, 17:24
by Big Red Machine
Haven't actually finished the PPV yet (and still spoiler-free), but I gave the women's match the full 10.

Re: Your 5 star matches

Posted: Sep 26th, '16, 22:31
by cero2k
Cotc? Really?

Re: Your 5 star matches

Posted: Sep 26th, '16, 23:59
by Big Red Machine
cero2k wrote:Cotc? Really?
Yeah. Masterful storytelling.

Re: Your 5 star matches

Posted: Oct 1st, '16, 23:03
by Big Red Machine
Ladder War VI makes it two in a week!

Re: Your 5 star matches

Posted: Oct 11th, '16, 23:20
by cero2k
I don't believe it, but two months short of ending the year, Okada and Marufuji may have just dethroned Naito/Omega for the MOTY. Tye Dillinger Match!

Re: Your 5 star matches

Posted: Dec 2nd, '16, 14:33
by Big Red Machine
Just added Cole vs. Lethal from ROH Reach for the Sky Tour: London

Re: Your 5 star matches

Posted: Jan 20th, '17, 13:59
by Big Red Machine
Just added the Jimmy Havoc vs. Sammy Smooth I Quit match from IPW:UK Supershow 5. You're going to want to watch this one spoiler-free, so don't read my review yet.